Close-up of assorted cookies arranged diagonally on a light surface, including chocolate chip cookies, a bright blue cookie with white chunks, and a tan cookie with pink filling.
An open kraft cardboard gift box labeled 'THE OFFERING' containing six individually wrapped chocolate chip cookies in assorted flavors, arranged on a light beige surface.
A single chocolate chip cookie with a banana chunk, photographed from directly above on a light beige surface.
An overhead flat-lay of assorted cookies on a white surface, including chocolate chip cookies, red velvet cookies, and two uniquely decorated cookies with eyes and a pink/red split design.
A close-up of a person's hands pulling a chocolate chip cookie apart, showing a stretchy melted chocolate center, on a light neutral background.
Three stacked chocolate chip cookie bars with melted chocolate chips, photographed close-up on a light neutral background.
A tall stack of assorted cookies, including chocolate chip cookies, red velvet cookies, and green tea cookie, photographed on a light marble surface with a soft white marble background.
Mystery NY Cookie Box
Mystery NY Cookie Box
Packaged red velvet cookies with a visible brand label held by a hand against a blurred green background.
A hand holding a round split cookie, with one half pink and the other half olive green, against a plain beige background.
Mystery NY Cookie Box
Box of assorted cookies with clear packaging and visible branding on a wooden surface
Mystery NY Cookie Box
Mystery NY Cookie Box

Mystery NY Cookie Box

$37.00
Choose your box

NZ wide delivery: Shipping calculated at checkout.

Click & collect: Usually ready within 24 hours. Order by 2pm Mon–Thu for next-day pickup. Orders after 2pm Thursday and Fri–Sun are ready Monday.

Please note: Before placing your order, please review our Online Ordering Terms & Conditions and Ingredients & Allergen Information.

Fancy a little Bakehouse roulette?

The Mystery Box is a surprise selection of Bakehouse NY Cookies, chosen by us from whatever Mr O and the Bakehouse crew are baking at the time.

Choose a box of 6 or 12 and leave the rest to us. You’ll get a mix of favourites, current flavours and, if you’re lucky, you might even find one of Mr O’s latest creations before it has made it into the café.

No choosing. No overthinking. Just open the box and see what you scored.

Perfect for sharing, gifting, taking to the office or keeping entirely to yourself. We won’t judge.

Choose your box

6 Cookies
A surprise selection of 6 Bakehouse NY Cookies.

12 Cookies
A bigger surprise selection of 12 Bakehouse NY Cookies.

 

Big cookies. Proper ingredients. Baked in Greytown.

Our Bakehouse NY Cookies are generously sized, loaded with the good stuff and baked right here in Greytown.

Available for New Zealand wide delivery or click and collect.